| Season | Year | Record | Result | Champions |
| Summer | 2019 | 1-1 | Semi-Finalist | Ice Breakers |
| Spring | 2019 | 2-2 | Finalist | Yaks |
| Winter | 2019 | 1-1 | Semi-Finalist | Ice-o-topes |
| Fall | 2018 | 0-1 | Quarter-Finalist | Sasquatch |
| Summer | 2018 | 1-1 | Semi-Finalist | Sasquatch |
| Spring | 2018 | 0-1 | Wild Card | Ypsi Aces |
| Winter | 2018 | 1-1 | Quarter-Finalist | Puckings |
| Fall | 2017 | 1-1 | Semi-Finalist | Ice-o-topes |
| Summer | 2017 | 1-1 | Semi-Finalist | Ice Breakers |
| Spring | 2017 | 0-1 | Quarter-Finalist | Black Bears |
| Winter | 2017 | 4-0 | Champions | Ashley’s Hopslam |
| Fall | 2016 | 0-1 | Quarter-Finalist | Ice-o-topes |
| Summer | 2016 | 0-1 | Quarter-Finalist | Med Wings |
| Spring | 2016 | 1-1 | Semi-Finalist | Ice Dogs |
| Winter | 2016 | 2-2 | Finalist | Sasquatch |
| Fall | 2015 | 1-1 | Semi-Finalist | Ice Men |
| Summer | 2015 | 0-1 | Quarter-Finalist | Ice Breakers |
| Spring | 2015 | 1-1 | Semi-Finalist | Ice Dogs |
| Winter | 2015 | 0-1 | Quarter-Finalist | Cleveland Steamers |
| Fall | 2014 | 4-0 | Champions | Ashley’s Hopslam |
| Summer | 2014 | 3-0 | Champions | Ashley’s Hopslam |
| Spring | 2014 | 0-1 | Quarter-Finalist | St. Anky Beer |
| Winter | 2014 | 0-1 | Semi-Finalist | Yaks |
| Fall | 2013 | 1-1 | Semi-Finalist | Yaks |
| Summer | 2013 | 0-1 | Semi-Finalist | Yaks |
| Spring | 2013 | 0-1 | Quarter-Finalist | Depot Town Stags |